Exploits in Sustainability
Exploits in sustainability
Many companies have now adopted an eco-friendly approach and some companies are literally turning their logos green. Few companies are prepared to exploit the meaning of ‘green’ in order to increase sales and broaden their consumer market; this term is commonly known as ‘greenwashing’.
If the actions of an organisation contradict the principles they endorse then they will suffer being criticised by both the consumer and other organisations, predominantly eco friendly ones. The whole identity of the brand will be questioned if they over promote and under perform. Eco friendly organisations are more than willing to criticise when brands are not backing up their green image.
Greenwashing is described as “…the practice of making an unsubstantiated or misleading claim about the environmental benefits of a product, service, technology or company practice”, in short, it is dishonesty.
(Search CRM. Greenwashing http://searchcrm.techtarget.com/definition/greenwashing)
It is now becoming very popular to stick a green leaf, tree or field in logos to try to distinguish eco-friendly companies from non-sustainable ones. But do organisations, services etc understand what ‘green’ means, or are they purposely selling themselves to gain more trust through deceit?
Case Study: BP Global
BP, one of the worlds leading oil companies, provides worldwide coverage of all gas and energy supplies. The global brand has a daily refined product sale of 5,927 thousand barrels (based on 2011 figures), has over 22,000 retail sites and is active in over 70 countries for product marketing and retail.
The ‘Worst US Environment Disaster’, as described by the BBC News, was the headline for what happened in the Gulf of Mexico. The spill affected more then 20 miles of Louisiana Coastline by spilling at least 20 million gallons into the Gulf.
The oil spill lasted for such a long time, longer than any expert predicted, it was classed as the world’s worst oil spill, and with all the effects that persisted as a result, it is easy to see why the headlines were spot on.
The BP logo was first created in 1920; from then on the logo was a shield with the initials BP contained within. The logo could then be used with any colour scheme as seen fit or to be kept as its bare black and white icon, and as time went on the colour scheme of green and yellow became the standard choice. BP states that this decision is “something of a mystery.” The shield was the iconic badge that helped carry the brand’s name and image for 80 years until 2000 when they decided on a new approach.
At the beginning of the 21stcentury BP (now a cluster of companies including Aral, ARCO and Castrol) unveiled a new emblem to link all of the brands together as one. The new logo consists of 3 colours; green, yellow and white, and resembles the Greek sun god, Helios. BP describes the Helios as a symbol of “…dynamic energy in all its forms.”
At the beginning of the 21stcentury BP (now a cluster of companies including Aral, ARCO and Castrol) unveiled a new emblem to link all of the brands together as one. The new logo consists of 3 colours; green, yellow and white, and resembles the Greek sun god, Helios. BP describes the Helios as a symbol of “…dynamic energy in all its forms.”
So how is BP ensuring that they are sticking by their Helios logo and not greenwashing to gain deceitful trust from the consumer? Since the disaster in the Gulf of Mexico in 2010 BP have been investing millions into their sustainable adverts and have recently released a new TV ad for the 2012 Olympics. The T.V spot was created by Ogilvy & Mather, and there were high hopes it would boost popularity with global consumers.
“Dedicated to fuelling the success of London 2012, [BP] will be providing fuel for over 5000 games vehicles, looking to provide lower energy fuels and aiming to offset the carbon footprint.”
(Marketing Week. BP launch first TV ad since gulf of Mexico oil spill. http://www.marketingweek.co.uk/bp-launches-first-tv-ad-since-gulf-of-mexico-oil-spill/3028071.article)
Greenpeace
Greenpeace are an independent, not for profit, campaigning organisation. Their vision is described as wanting to change the views we, as people, have on the Earth; “We want governments, industry and each and every person to stop viewing the Earth as an inexhaustible resource and start treating it as something precious that needs our protection and careful management.” They start at the effected areas and work with the surrounding communities and supporters to trace the culprits responsible for the problems caused.
Greenpeace set a live brief to redesign BP’s logo (Beyond Petroleum). The winning logo was to be used in campaigns against the oil company. The winner of the competition was to be offered a day with a graphic designer to portray their ideas across from a professional perspective. This decision to have BP’s logo rebranded has made it clear that Greenpeace hold strong beliefs in sustainability. Greenpeace were prepared to stand up against BP, who they believed were delivering a false sustainable identity. The competition was a way of enabling people globally to understand what BP were doing to the environment.
Many logos were entered into the competition, (over 2000) with more then 25,000 votes and 2,000,000 hits. The winner of the competition by most votes was Laurent Hunziker from France. His inspiration for the idea was a thrilling one. The logo features the original BP logo with a silhouette of a bird drowning in oil. He explains that ‘…His [the bird] agony is a strong reflection of what is happening to our world with these tragic events’, finishing with an interesting few words; ‘…and it all looks like a fatal sunset for us.’
The ‘judges choice’ winner was Alexander Hettich from Germany. His logo also shows the Beyond Petroleum Helios in the background with the oil spill at the bottom of the icon. Hettich gets to the point and meaning behind the logo directly; “It's the face of the BP sunset: the shining green brand - which suggests a clean ecological image - drowns in a pitch black, dirty, sticky, puddle of oil.”
What pushed the judges’ choice towards this piece? Probably the same reason anyone else would, it is iconic, memorable and gets straight to the point. The judges say ‘The image of BP's sunflower disappearing into a sea of oil also communicates that the sun is going down on BP's dirty business. The greenwash hasn't worked and the decision to turn its back on the 'Beyond Petroleum' mantra has cost lives…’
So, are BP actually making a small change, and contributing to the environment? There is still a sense of suspicion in the air on whether they are just planting the green label on their identity for the sake of getting eco-friendlies to leave them alone and diverting attention away from their major drilling sites, Canadian tar pits being one of them. Being ‘green’ is the message, and BP still have a long way to go to deliver it.
Our next upcoming article will be: Exploits in sustainability – McDonalds,contains a case study on McDonalds and their involvement with sustainability.



Comments
Post a Comment